What’s true, in response to Littlefeather, is that she felt harassed and discriminated in opposition to for her speech for a lot of the remainder of her life and profession, saying she’d been effectively blacklisted by the leisure trade. By the top of the 70s, after some small appearances in a handful of films like Freebie & the Bean and a few Playboy spreads, any showbusiness profession she may need had appears to have sputtered out. In June final 12 months, the Academy issued Littlefeather a formal apology, and subsequently hosted “a night of dialog, therapeutic and celebration” with the activist solely a month or so earlier than she handed away aged 75 in October. Undoubtedly, the apology was lengthy overdue.
A twist within the story
Complicating issues additional, Littlefeather’s personal Yacqui and Apache background has been referred to as into query through the years, most lately on this San Francisco Chronicle piece. Whether it is to be believed, there are deep-rooted racial and moral points connected to Littlefeather and her look on stage that night. If Littlefeather was truly “Pretendian”, as those that falsely declare to be Native American are typically referred to as, it could complicate the earnest righteousness of the gesture, and lift questions on tips on how to choose Brando’s selection to make use of her as his mouthpiece.
Nevertheless, the info stay cloudy: the author of the piece, Jacqueline Keeler, has been challenged on a few of her fact-finding by Native American group members, making the figuring out of Littlefeather’s heritage a murky proposition.
Adam Piron, the director of the indigenous programme at Sundance Institute, says: “For me, it is a non-issue to some extent. Whether or not she was or wasn’t enrolled within the tribes she claimed, she clearly had a number of acceptance from leaders in our group, who knew about these allegations. The factor that occurred with Brando with the Oscars had such an estimable impression in the true world: you are in a position to measure what she did when it comes to [breaking] the [media] blackout [around Wounded Knee, where the US Justice Department banned journalists], and the way that began to vary precise coverage and laws round Native People due to visibility.”
Contemplating the textual content of Brando’s full assertion, which Littlefeather was not allowed to learn in full on the night however was later shared with the press, it appears troublesome to not see to the center of the matter:
“It has not been my want to offend or diminish the significance of those that are collaborating tonight,” Brando’s full assertion mentioned. “Maybe at this second, you’re saying to your self, what the hell has this received to do with the Academy Awards? […] the movement image trade has been as accountable as any for degrading the Indian. When Indian youngsters watch tv and so they watch movies, and so they see their race depicted as they’re in movies, their minds turn out to be injured in methods we will by no means know. If we’re not our brother’s keeper, at the least allow us to not be his executioner.”
Basically, questions over Littlefeather’s exact heritage don’t reduce the message she delivered – and by extension, Brando’s intention to carry consciousness to the plight of Native People and to their years of insulting and outright racist representation on-screen.
“I believe it is as much as indigenous individuals to determine how they really feel about Littlefeather’s heritage,” says Piron. “However due to her actions and the platform Brando allowed this trigger to have, there was a measurable impression. […] It was part of a bigger effort that set the stage for every thing that was to comply with – elevated activism throughout indigenous communities, far more consciousness from non-indigenous communities of what our rights have been. And totally different federal insurance policies round elevated recognition of indigenous peoples’ sovereignty from a authorized standpoint, whereas earlier than, the thought of US coverage was primarily going to be the termination of the id of the Native American, so he would simply be an American.”
Brando – a exceptional actor and a long-time supporter of civil rights, who took half within the 1963 March on Washington – undeniably had his coronary heart in the precise place, and in a really fashionable one, at that, in his invocation of kids, cinema, and illustration – and as Piron factors out, what he and Littlefeather selected to do made a distinction that many exterior of the indigenous group could not realise. “It sort of flipped the dynamic of the media blackout and the erasure of what was occurring. Individuals have been trying away, and this type of pressured individuals to go and have a look at it.”
It might be that the behaviour of some hundred attendees of some of the unique and famend Hollywood occasions looks as if the stuff of superficial movie star gossip or tabloid fodder. However it’s clear that such Oscars furores usually have extra to say than first meets the attention.
It stands to purpose, given how audiences are used to projecting values and traits onto movie stars. So simply because the Will Smith/Chris Rock incident sparked a discourse round racial dynamics, showbiz energy, magnificence requirements, and the acceptability of violence, the Brando/Littlefeather incident has turn out to be a litmus take a look at round movie star activism, political divisiveness within the trade, and the real-world efficacy of creating statements from such a platform. Through the years, awards controversies like this one have proved a dependable – if usually out-of-left-field – bellwether for essentially the most bruising and provocative topics in our tradition and society at massive. Let’s hold on tight for Oscars 2023 and see if something can high it.
Love movie and TV? Be a part of BBC Culture Film and TV Club on Fb, a group for cinephiles everywhere in the world.
If you want to touch upon this story or anything you may have seen on BBC Tradition, head over to our Facebook web page or message us on Twitter.
And in case you favored this story, sign up for the weekly bbc.com features newsletter, referred to as The Important Record. A handpicked choice of tales from BBC Future, Tradition, Worklife and Journey, delivered to your inbox each Friday.
